Genealogy Chat

Hi Maggie,
Unforunately I did not know my aunt Isabella and what you say makes a lot of sense.

I had thought she had been named after her aunt Isabella Martin Stevenson, and then wondered if her that aunt might have given birth pre marriage, the child having then being cared for by her elder sister & husband (my grandparents). There is no birth registration for such a child, but she might have been taken in as a Weston child right after birth?

As said earlier, Isabella M.'s birth was registered Jun Qtr 1908 & Isabella's was Sep Qtr 1908. There are two birth registrations, but as you say, they could be of the same girl. Thus, when both birth certs. arrive, if they demonstrate the same parentage for both girls, I still may not have an answer to my conundrum?

Yet, as you may correctly say, the untimely death of the 14 year old Isabella may have been the passing of 'both' girls. Consequently there would be no certification of marriage or death for two girls. Although I may get evidence of the birth of two girls. Can't wait for the certs, which I will report upon on their arrival.

That is a BRILLIANT analysis, Maggie, take a bow!!!

Thanks & regards, Jimmy

Jimmy,
Just had another thought. Did you know your aunt Isabella?
If not, this may be because both Isabellas are, after all, the same person!!
My dad was adopted and his 'birth' is registered 4 times!!
Twice under his mother's maiden name and twice under his adopted name - I personally think some mistakes were made, and he should have been registered twice: once under his mother's maiden name (she was unmarried) and once under his adoptive name, 14 years later when my gran married.

Perhaps your Isabella is registered under her original
name (Isabella Weston), then re-registered when she was adopted a few months later by someone in the family with the same surname, and she died aged 14.

maggie

Hi Christine, many thanks for that most interesting snippet of our social history, it is difficult to comprehend such happenings to those unfortunate children. Imagine, though distasteful as it is, such a thing happening to our own children of today. Doesn't bear thinking about.

I look forward to reading your board full of miscellaneous particulars - sounds interesting.

Regards, Jimmy

!!! A BIG THANK YOU !!!

I would like to thank ALL who responded so positively to my request regarding 'My Mysterious Isabella'. Your thoughts and suggestions are very much appreciated and will be employed in resolving my genealogical enigma. I will let you know when it is done.

Thanks & regards, Jimmy

Hi Christine,

Many thanks for your response and most interesting information, for I had very little Idea that our ancestors were allowed to marry at such an imature age. As my aunt was born in 1908 she would easily come under those terms, and your advice, which is most appreciated, gives me other angles to work with.

I am not sure sure yet if my Weston's reached that far north yet, but they were well domiciled in Yorkshire.

Thank & regards, Jimmy

Hi Ruby,

I agree that such a thing often happened in families of those times, although in this case there appear to be two registered dates of birth for the two Isabellas. No doubt the answer will be simple when discovered, and I thank you for your good advice.

At the moment I have no Weston's in Brighton, although mine appear to have migrated all over the country it seems.

Many thanks for replying - it is very much appreciated.
Regards, Jimmy

Hi Ozi,

Yes, that thought has occurred, hope it is that easy at the end of the day.

Regards, jimmy

Jimmy, let us know when the certs arrive. It would be interesting to know how they are connected.

Selena

Possibly they were cousins.

Ozi.

Hi Carol,

Many thanks for good your suggestion of the two Isabella's being the same one, but unfortunately I have the two sets of birth details. The adopted Isabella unfortunately died aged only fourteen, but it seems that both girls were registered at birth as 'Weston'. Obviously both could not have been born of my grandmother being only 3 or 4 months apart.

It will be interesting to see the birth certs. If they have both been registered as 'Weston', it might indicate that the adopted Isabella must have been someone very close to the family.

Thanks again for your input - which is very much appreciated. Regards, Jimmy

Jimmy, I have Weston's from Wellington. I will send you a PM.

Regards,

Selena

Hi Selena,

Thanks for taking the time to reply, it is much appreciated. You may be interested to know that my Weston's are originally from such places as Prees, Morton Say, Lee Brockhurst, Wellington, Darliston + a Wolverhampton connection + the name Maddox. The earliest date being 1763 - If anything rings a bell I hope you will come back to me.

I like your idea of the two Isabella's being the same person, it would make life much easier, though I have their two registered birth dates and the death of one of them. Having said that, the certs seem to be taking their time in coming, although it is holiday season.

Isabella Martin is named after her aunt Isabella Martin Stevenson, unfortunately I have not come across the name of Martin in their ancestry yet.

Thanks & regards, Jimmy

Hello Jimmy, I was interested as I have Weston's in my tree but they are from Shropshire and much earlier on.

Do you know why Isabella had Martin in her name? Could this be her mother's maiden name or another family name? Do the siblings have Martin in their names?

One other thought, have you searched for anything using a double-barrelled surname?

Let us know how you get on,
Selena

Hi Jimmy

It would be very confusing to have two children in the same house, with the same name. You may find when you receive the certificates that they are actually the same person. This has happened twice in my family tree.

Good Luck

Carol

Hi Christine,

Many thanks for such refreshing & encouraging council. I never thought of starting my searches at age sixteen, rather thought twenty would be about right, seeing as none of her twelve brothers and sisters wed below that age. You have given me hope and other roads to go down, which was what I was seeking. So all my thanks to you. regards, Jimmy

Hi Brenda,

Thank you so much for taking the time to look at my request, it really is appreciated! The info you have gleaned matches mine exactly, unfortunately the lady of Birkenhead, which as you will know is very close to Liverpool, is not the lady I am seeking.

As I have become bogged down with it, I thought I would ask the experts here. I know it is a toughie - otherwise I wouldn't have asked.
Thanks again Brenda, your efforts are applauded! Jimmy

Yes Reg! I am fully aware what a task it is, for I have been trying to resolve it for some time. Just thought a fresh approach might have been helpful - obviously not.

Thanks, Jim

Mr Morgalla,

She was a sister of my late mother and the only details I have of her, are her birth details. Just trying to discover whatever became of her.

Thanks for your interest, Jimmy

I wonder if you realise what a task this would be? Firstly, it would involve viewing every marriage image from the time she became 16.........until ??????

And finding a death would be entirely dependant on whether one found a marriage.............or not.

I wish you luck...........

Reg

You appear to be working forwards, rather than backwards, which is much more difficult, especially as you can't access info such as censuses.. Is there any particular reason for this?